Category Archives: 2023

Rustin

Rustin                   3 ½ stars

I have seen news clips of the March on Washington of August 28, 1963 and read references to it dozens of times for decades. Dr. Martin Luther King’s speech of that day is legendary, but I had never heard of the organizer behind that event until seeing the movie Rustin by director George C. Wolfe (Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom). The movie focuses on Bayard Rustin (played by Colman Domingo of Zola, Selma and If Beale Street Could Talk), a civil rights leader of the era who was the person regarded as most responsible for pulling off this historic event. This movie has the distinction of having Barack and Michelle Obama among its executive directors, so it has some pretty high expectations. Since I had not heard this story before I read some more about it to see how accurate the movie is. It appears that Hollywood’s enthusiasm to create a moving story of a civil rights icon may have led to shading a few facts. A. Philip Randolph (portrayed by Glynn Turman in the movie) should have credit for proposing the march, but this seems to have been missed in the movie by giving Rustin the credit. The movie also doesn’t give much credit to the labor movement even though the UAW played a large part in this and other events of the period. From the movie, it would seem that Rustin almost alone was responsible for making the march happen. The movie ends with the conclusion of the march showing Rustin helping to clean up the Washington Mall instead of meeting with elected officials, leaving that to King and the other civil rights leaders. Therefore, it leaves out his later contributions to the movement in the mid-sixties. Colman Domingo, who has typically played supporting roles before, is quite effective in showing the determination and resilience of Rustin when faced with major hurdles. He deserves the role and rightly received an Academy Award nomination for the performance. There are several other notable appearances of actors in historical roles including Chris Rock as Roy Wilkins, leader of the NAACP, Audra McDonald as Ella Baker, CCH Pounder as Anna Hedgeman, Aml Ameen as Dr. King and of course, Jeffrey Wright as Representative Adam Clayton Powell. The writing probably doesn’t measure up to Oscar winning status though. The movie does not shy away from Rustin’s homosexuality, including his affairs and indiscretions that nearly got him removed from his organizing position. Domingo really owns the line “On the day that I was born Black, I was also born homosexual. They either believe in freedom and justice for all, or they do not.” In this respect it brings the struggle for gay rights into present terms. The movie deserves to be seen as long as one is aware of some shading of the truth.

Nyad

Nyad                     4 stars

It is Oscar season which is certainly clear from the number of A list actors that
have put in some notable performances in recent months. Certainly among them
are the two women appearing side by side in the true story of endurance swimmer
Diane Nyad simply called Nyad. Four-time Oscar nominee Annette Bening has the
title role of the woman who failed in her first attempt to swim from Cuba to
Florida, a distance of 103 miles in the open ocean in 1978, but then had the
vision to take up the challenge again at the age of 60. Jodie Foster has the
role of Bonnie Stoll, Nyad’s lifelong friend and coach who volunteers to be
with her to realize her dream to be the first to accomplish this seemingly
impossible feat. What stands out the most in this “biopic” is the close
personal bond this pair has, especially when they go toe to toe at each other
in highly emotional scenes. Add to this, a third character, their navigator,
John Bartlett (Rhys Ifans) who adds to the drama during the film’s many
harrowing moments. The film is the work of the pair Elizabeth Chai Vasarhelyi
and Jimmy Chin who have worked primarily on documentaries like Free Solo in the
past. Over the film’s two hours we get a steady dose of the challenges this
small group faced that include storms, a swift moving current, cold
temperatures, hallucinations and attacks from sharks and box jellyfish. We also
get a lesson in some of the science involved in such a feat of human endurance
such as the nutrition needed, the equipment used to defend from sea creature attacks
(Nyad did not use a shark cage) and the navigation methods employed. An
important element is the encouragement from Bonnie she gives to Nyad during
moments of disorientation and confusion. The scenes have a very real sense to
them. Interspersed throughout the movie are actual footage of Nyad’s first
attempt at the swim when she was 28 and flashbacks to her childhood and time
with her father. The movie may seem predictable at times, but it is made
memorable by the performances of Bening and Foster, both of whom are well above
the age of most women having major roles in movies today. It’s rare to have two
in the same film and rarer still to have two with Academy Award Acting
nominations at the same time which is true for Nyad.